An Animated Dissection: My Top 5 favorite animated characters, supervised by Glen Keane

Last week, I received some shocking news that made me realize how time had continued to move forward.

One of the Walt Disney Studio’s master animators, Glen Keane, officially announced his retirement. Much like Walt Disney became a fixture in the minds of many due to his appearances on the Disneyland television show, Glen became stuck in my mind as I saw him discuss the animation of Ariel, in a making-of special for The Little Mermaid.

But what really cemented him in my mind, was the interview he did for the making of Beauty and the Beast, as well as the information that was gleaned from him in the updated version of Bob Thomas’ The Art Of Animation, released in the fall of 1991. Needless to say, I was enthralled by Keane’s art style. So much so, that I began to emulate it. However, unlike most animators, Keane was a man of many lines…literally. But the amount of lines that he laid down on a piece of paper, could often convey something much more than just a simple, clean line. I was surprised how much this had wormed its way into my brain, when I showed someone some rough and clean drawings for some personal projects. “The rough drawings look better,” they said, “they have more personality.”

In recent years, I guess it has been hard to believe that the men who worked on the films when I was a kid have grown up as well (I remember being shocked seeing directors John Musker and Ron Clements with grey hair when doing interviews for Treasure Planet!). Much like time aged the former Nine Old Men of Disney’s animation division, the same has happened to the young men who were mentored and taught the principles to them.

With Glen’s exit from the hallowed halls of Disney’s Feature Animation division, I thought I’d list my Top 5 favorite animated characters that Glen had a hand in their creation and supervision. So, away we go!

5. John Silver (voiced by Brian Murray)

As computers began to creep into the animation division at Walt Disney Feature Animation in the early 2000’s, a number of key animated items began to be relegated to cel-shaded computer models, and some animators began to shy away from the changes. However, Keane actually embraced the technology, and with Treasure Planet‘s concept of ‘Treasure Island in Space,’ chose to make the original John Silver’s missing hand and peg leg be cybernetic substitutions/attachments.  While many tore Treasure Planet asunder, I have a soft spot for Keane’s work on Silver, an alien creature who is trapped at a crossroads in his life, but finds himself becoming an unofficial guardian to Jim Hawkins. In the audio commentary for Planet, Keane makes mention of a football coach who encouraged him after the loss of a football game, and pushed him on. When one hears that, it’s like those emotions definitely flowed into the character of Silver. As well, Keane brings a graceful and awe-inspiring fluidity to Silver’s movements, making his preparation of a meal almost as graceful as a ballet dancer, and his rolling around of the name ‘Billy Bones’ just as fascinating. The pronunciation scene shows some wonderful squash-and-stretch that reminded me of the awe some animators felt with former Disney Animator Milt Kahl’s work on Medusa in The Rescuers.


4. Professor Ratigan (voiced by Vincent Price)

When it comes to having a mouse version of Sherlock Holmes (aka Basil of Baker Street), a precision mind like that needs a nefarious criminal mind to thwart and torture his sub-conscious. Such a figure was the imposingly large Professor Ratigan. This was one of Keane’s first major gigs as a Supervising Animator for a main character, and after proving he could give a powerful performance out of a larger character (the bear during the climactic fight-scene in The Fox and the Hound), Ratigan moved Keane into the territory of an animal with intellect. Emotionally, Keane helped establish Ratigan as a character who appears to be sophisticated, but underneath, lurks an angry rat ready to bubble to the surface. Certainly, this comes into play in the climactic clock fight on Big Ben, where Ratigan goes through an almost Jekyll-and-Hyde like transformation as he confronts Basil. Some people I have talked with have even said that scene was terrifying. Of course, it’s also interesting to consider the voice of the rather slim Vincent Price coming from such a large character, but the work is done so well, that you soon stop thinking ‘Vincent Price,’ and just start thinking ‘that’s Ratigan.’


3. Tarzan (voiced by Tony Goldwyn)

In 1999, I just couldn’t contain my excitement at the prospect of seeing Tarzan. Once I saw the teaser poster showing him sketched in charcoal pencil, I knew I was going to be there on opening day. Keane’s artistry and love of the original Burroughs’ story really seemed to influence Tarzan’s design, and with the use of animation, Tarzan could be made to more ‘easily’ mimic the pose and movements of the apes he lived with. I still am fascinated by the hands and feet of Tarzan, just the way he curls his hands to look like an ape’s as he moves along the ground, and the way the toes on his feet splay out. Just like Keane would embrace the use of a computer/hand-drawn character hybrids with Silver a few years later, his work making Tarzan move through 3-dimensional backgrounds definitely captured many of our imaginations in the Summer of 1999.


2. Ariel (voiced by Jodi Benson)

Probably no Top 5 list of Keane characters would be complete without this fiery redhead. Ariel was Keane’s first major foray into doing a lead female character. Word was when someone asked Keane why he wanted to tackle a character like Ariel, he explained that he had to. Of course, one could almost look at Glen, a former football player in high school, and not realize that this man got into the mindset of a 16-year-old girl, and made her situation and emotions real to so many. But of course, that’s the beauty of animation: you become any character regardless of what you look like (animators are ‘actors with pencils,’ after all). The second half of Mermaid is also memorable, because Ariel becomes a silent character for much of that time, and it’s through little movements and gestures that we get some well-played emotional scenes. It also helps that her eyes are so large to help convey her emotions. Though when it comes to large-eyed heroines, one can definitely see Keane’s influence on Rapunzel all these years later, making her a lithe and effervescent personality too.


1. The Beast (voiced by Robbie Benson)

Ever since the fall of 1991, The Beast has been my favorite Disney character. I always remember David Ogden Stiers in the making-0f special for the film Beauty and the Beast proposing an interesting conundrum regarding this creation: “How do you draw a monster, and make him lovable?” Keane got right to the heart of the matter with the Beast: a being both man and animal, yet stuck at an uncomfortable crossroads, where one of the last remaining vestiges of his humanity are his eyes. It was also the design of the Beast that I just fell in love with. While many earlier works of the fairy tale had used more common animal heads like those of a Mandrill, Keane’s final take consisted of a creature comprised of the parts of 7 different animals. This combination could have looked alien or foreign, but the final combination looks like it could most definitely exist in our world. From a wolf’s hind legs, to the body of a bear, and even the neck and head posture of a bison, alot of attention and detail was made, with Keane even diagramming the skeleton of the Beast and making copious notes for his animation crew to follow. It almost feels like the Beast owes a little thanks to Keane’s work on Professor Ratigan, as both of these characters are large and taper down to spindly legs, yet even at their size, they can emote with even the smallest of moments.

One of the scenes that Glen did was the Beast’s Transformation at the end of the film. While I was awe-inspired and left with goosebumps, it wasn’t until I saw Keane’s original rough animation drawings of the scene on the Beauty and the Beast special features DVD, did I feel that something got lost in the translation, when his rough line-art was cleaned to pristine clean-up animation. Below, I’ve included 7 stills from Glen’s rough pencil-animation of the Beast’s Transformation:

There’s so much incredible artistry packed into these scenes. Ordinarily, animators aren’t supposed to add shadow and light to their work, but Glen works in a league all his own, and as we can see above, it helps bring a depth to his work that makes it even better. In fact, let’s compare Glen’s rough art of the Prince’s reveal, with a shot from the completed film. I remember alot of people didn’t like the final design of the Prince in the film, but if he looked like the Prince in Keane’s rough pencil animation, would you give him a chance?

(Left) Keane's rough animation of the Prince, (Right) The final image from the film


Please bear in mind that this is only my top 5 list, and while I may have left off other characters Keane animated like Marahute the Golden Eagle, Aladdin, and Pocahontas, they still are incredibly inspiring pieces of work. In many interviews and sound bites, I’ve heard Keane get very, very enthused when he talks about what he’s done. On the DVD of Waking Sleeping Beauty, he discusses  how he wanted Marahute the Golden Eagle’s flight to be so uplifting, that the audience feels like they’re flying right along with her and the little boy in the film named Cody. I remember seeing the film opening weekend and really being impressed by that scene, so Glen definitely did his job!

One of the key ingredients that Glen was taught by the remaining Nine Old Men of Disney Animation, was to ‘animate emotions.’ At first, Glen had no real clue what that meant (pressing harder on the paper doesn’t bring about better animation). But soon, he realized that if he went into a character or scene with the intensity of the emotions and a feeling inside of him, then it could work. This is true in the scene in Tarzan, where Tarzan touches Jane’s hand, and there’s a quiet moment shared between them. In an interview on the Tarzan DVD set, Keane said that for this moment, he held onto the memory of when his daughter was born, and the image of Tarzan looking at Jane, was how Keane felt when he saw his daughter for the first time.

Though I never did achieve my pre-teen dream of one day becoming a Disney Animator and being a part of Glen’s animation team, I often loved to keep reading up on what he was doing at Disney. For me, just hearing that some of my favorite animators were working on a project was enough to get me excited about it (one of the reasons why I was going to see Treasure Planet despite what any said about it).

One place I’d recommend to go, if you have an iPod or an MP3 player, is The Animation Podcast . Clay Kaytis works for Disney, and in the last 5 years, sat down with a number of people who worked there, and got them to tell a bit about their thought processes, and their climb up the animation ladder. Glen sat down for a 2-part interview, and you can also find interviews by the likes of Andreas Deja (Supervising Animator on King Triton, Gaston, and Scar), Eric Goldberg (Supervising Animator on The Genie), and Nik Ranieri (Supervising Animator on Lumiere, Rafiki, and Hades).

Well, I’ve rambled enough, but just in case Glen (or someone he knows) stumbles onto this page while Googling, let me just say thank you for your inspiration, and good luck on the next leg of your journey.

Of all the different pictures of Glen that have been taken, this is the one that I always remember: the small image of him in Bob Thomas' "The Art of Animation: From Mickey Mouse to Beauty and the Beast."


Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About MWH1980

Growing up in the state of Iowa, one would assume I'd be enamored with pigs and corn. Well, I wasn't. Instead, I grew fascinated by many things that were entertainment-related. Things like movies, animation, toys, books, and many more kept my attention. This blog I hope to use to express myself regarding my varied obsessions. (P.S. There's no Photoshop involved in that Gravatar-I really am holding an Oscar)

2 responses to “An Animated Dissection: My Top 5 favorite animated characters, supervised by Glen Keane”

  1. manvsart says :

    Great Article! I especially liked your kind words about Treasure Planet, specifically Silver. I was fortunate enough to work on TP as Glen’s assistant and rough inbetweener. I’m the last animator trained by him in traditional animation and now I teach those lessons Ollie and Eric Larson taught Glen to CG students.


    • MWH1980 says :

      It’s always nice when my blog postings manage to be seen or heard by those like yourself!

      The media to me just did their usual gang-up on something with very little info (they definitely went DOA-crazy when ‘John Carter’ was coming out) when it came to Treasure Planet. I always consider it the last charge of the light-brigade before “The Dark Times” hit from 2004-2007.

      Though it was nice to see some of Glen throughout the design and characters in Tangled…just wish that story could have been a little tighter in places.

      It’s always been my dream to speak to Glen Keane or Andreas Deja. Sadly in the last 2 years, I’ve gotten within 10 ft of both of them at Disney events, before they were whisked away. And it seems every other animation fan I’ve spoken to in California has met Glen, or even got him to draw something.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: